Weighing the Options: Closing Credits vs. Price Reduction

When purchasing a home, there are several negotiating tactics you can use to make the process work to your benefit. Two of these tactics include asking for a closing credit or a price reduction. These are tools that can potentially save you money and impact your financial health in various ways. But how do you know which option is best for you? In this blog post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both closing credits and price reductions.

Closing Credits

A closing credit (also known as seller concessions) is a sum of money the seller gives you to offset the costs of your home purchase. These funds are not handed over to you directly, but they are instead applied to your closing costs.

Pros of Closing Credits:
  1. Immediate Savings: A closing credit can significantly reduce the amount you’ll need to bring to the closing table. This can be a boon if you’re struggling to accumulate enough cash for down payment plus closing costs.
  2. Increased Buying Power: If you’ve budgeted a specific amount for your purchase, including closing costs, a closing credit can allow you to look at slightly pricier homes, since the credit will reduce your total out-of-pocket costs.
Cons of Closing Credits:
  1. Higher Mortgage Amount: Since the sale price of the home remains the same, you may end up borrowing more, which could lead to a higher mortgage payment.
  2. Appraisal Risks: If the house doesn’t appraise for the agreed-upon purchase price, the seller might not be able to contribute the agreed-upon closing credit, potentially leaving you to cover more of the closing costs.

Price Reduction

A price reduction is exactly what it sounds like: the seller agrees to reduce the price of the home.

Pros of Price Reduction:
  1. Lower Mortgage Loan: A lower home price directly results in a smaller mortgage loan, meaning you’ll owe less money over the life of your loan.
  2. Less Interest Paid: With a lower mortgage loan, you’ll also be paying less interest over the life of the loan, which can save you a significant amount in the long run.
Cons of Price Reduction:
  1. Higher Initial Costs: Reducing the home price doesn’t alleviate the immediate closing costs. This means you’ll need to have enough cash on hand to cover these expenses.
  2. Less Room for Negotiation: If the seller has already agreed to lower the price, they may be less willing to negotiate on other aspects of the deal.


So, which one should you choose? The decision depends largely on your financial situation and long-term plans. If you’re more concerned about immediate out-of-pocket costs and you’re comfortable with potentially higher mortgage payments, closing credits may be a good choice. If, however, you’re focused on long-term financial stability and can handle the up-front costs, a price reduction might be more beneficial.

Remember to work closely with your real estate agent and financial advisor to navigate these decisions. Each home purchase is unique, and these professionals can help guide you to the option that makes the most sense for you.

Real estate transactions can be complex, but by understanding the various tools at your disposal, you can make informed decisions that are beneficial for your specific circumstances. The road to homeownership may have its twists and turns, but with careful planning, it can certainly lead you to your dream home.

Check out this article next

Buying a Home with No Money Down in Tennessee

Buying a Home with No Money Down in Tennessee

For most people, buying a home is a significant milestone. But, let's face it - the traditional down payment is often a huge barrier to…

Read Article